Top 50 New York Yankee Players of All Time


Few sports clubs have captivated people’s imaginations and emotions like the New York Yankees. The Yankees have been linked with baseball supremacy for nearly a century, their heritage ingrained into the very fabric of the game.

The team’s trademark pinstripes have been worn by some of the finest athletes to ever take the field, and its illustrious history is a tapestry of wins, records, and unforgettable moments.

From Babe Ruth, who turned baseball into a national obsession, to Lou Gehrig’s timeless elegance and Derek Jeter’s captivating charisma, the Yankees’ roster of icons seemed nearly endless.

From the booming ’20s to the contemporary dynasties of the ’90s, each period has produced its own heroes. We go through the history of baseball as we examine the best 50 New York Yankee players of all time, honoring the players who not only helped define their teams but also had a lasting impact on the game.

1. Babe Ruth

Charles M. Conlon, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The name Babe Ruth alone conjures up the absolute best of baseball glory. Ruth’s influence on the New York Yankees and the sport as a whole is enormous. He is widely considered as one of the greatest athletes in history.

As “The Sultan of Swat,” he redefined power hitting and smashed towering home runs at a rate that had never been seen before, drastically altering the game. Beyond his prodigious hitting, Ruth became a cultural hero and a representation of the Roaring Twenties thanks to his larger-than-life demeanor.

The 1927 “Murderer’s Row” season was one of his era-defining achievements, and it continues to be legendary, solidifying Babe Ruth’s status as the archetypal Yankee and baseball’s undisputed icon.

2. Lou Gehrig

Lou Gehrig, often known as “The Iron Horse,” exemplified perseverance and greatness. His record of 2,130 games played continuously was evidence of his everlasting commitment. Few players could equal Gehrig’s consistency in hitting and fielding.

In addition to his extraordinary skills, he displayed elegance and humility, exemplifying the spirit of sportsmanship. Tragically, Lou Gehrig’s disease—now more widely referred to as ALS—cut short his career.

His farewell address at Yankee Stadium in 1939, during which he referred to himself as “the luckiest man on the face of the earth,” is still remembered as a key milestone in sports history. Lou Gehrig’s influence extends beyond baseball, and his bravery and integrity have inspired many others.

3. Mickey Mantle

Bowman Gum, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Mickey Mantle, a name synonymous with baseball greatness, provided the New York Yankees with a unique blend of power and speed. He was a switch-hitter who went by the moniker “The Mick,” and each of his at-bats had the potential to be a pivotal one.

Mantle established himself as one of the game’s top sluggers with his 536 career home runs, many of which were shot with mind-blowing power. Despite several injuries, his center-field agility contributed to his renown.

Mickey won over admirers all around the country with his charisma and country-boy charm. Even though he battled personal issues, Mantle’s reputation endures as a testament to the Yankees’ heyday and the promise of greatness.

4. Joe DiMaggio

As “The Yankee Clipper,” Joe DiMaggio was a baseball legend whose grace and dependability made him a revered figure in the history of the game. DiMaggio’s incredible 56-game hitting streak from 1941 is still regarded as one of the most prized milestones in the sport.

In addition to his offensive skills, his deft center-field performance established a benchmark for outfield greatness. He was a major member of the Yankees’ dynasty in the 1930s and 1940s and was a three-time MVP.

DiMaggio’s mystique was enhanced by his cool attitude and grace off the field. His influence on the Yankees and baseball is still felt today, creating a legacy of brilliance and serving as a reminder of the golden age of the national sport.

5. Derek Jeter

Y2kcrazyjoker4, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Throughout his brilliant career, Derek Jeter, sometimes known as “The Captain,” was the lifeblood of the New York Yankees. The club won several titles under Jeter’s leadership, and his clutch play helped him establish himself as one of the game’s all-time best shortstops.

He became a famous character in the Bronx thanks to his outstanding fielding and incredible batting consistency. In playoff play, Jeter’s flare for the dramatic earned him the nickname “Mr. November.

Beyond his on-field accomplishments, he set an example for aspiring baseball players with his leadership and dedication to the sport. Baseball and the Yankees will never be the same after Derek Jeter’s departure.

6. Mariano Rivera

Everyone agrees that Mariano Rivera, sometimes known as “Mo,” is the best closer in baseball history. For over two decades, his hallmark pitch—the cut fastball—confused batters.

The Yankees’ championship triumphs were largely due to Rivera’s domination in the ninth inning, which earned him the moniker “Sandman” for his capacity to lull opposition hitters to sleep.

His legacy is unmatched with a record 652 career saves and an unheard-of five World Series rings. Beyond his on-field prowess, Rivera set an example for other players with his humility and sportsmanship.

The New York Yankees and baseball as a whole have been forever changed by Mariano Rivera, whose influence extends beyond the field of play.

7. Yogi Berra

Bowman Gum, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Yogi Berra was a beloved and well-known character in baseball in addition to being a Hall of Fame catcher. His renowned humor and wisdom, frequently communicated through “Yogi-isms,” won him a loyal following. Berra was a strong defensive catcher behind the plate and an important part of many championship teams.

He was a three-time MVP and a 15-time All-Star. Berra was a master at managing pitchers and making game calls. His exceptional accomplishment is attested to by the 10 World Series rings he has.

Yogi became one of the sport’s most adored ambassadors off the field thanks to his amiable demeanor and sense of humor. Yogi Berra’s influence goes beyond numbers, indelible in the annals of baseball history.

8. Whitey Ford

Whitey Ford, sometimes referred to as “The Chairman of the Board,” was the master of the New York Yankees’ playoff play. Ford’s deft left-handed pitching contributed significantly to the team’s success in the 1950s and the first few years of the 1960s.

His 236 career victories made him the winningest pitcher in the history of the team. Ford was an All-Star 10 times and a Cy Young Award winner. He won the World Series MVP twice thanks to his exceptional capacity to perform under pressure.

He was a pitcher’s pitcher thanks to his fine control and broad pitching arsenal. Because of his ability to perform under pressure and his crucial contribution to the Yankees’ championship history, Whitey Ford will forever be remembered as a Yankees icon.

9. Reggie Jackson

New York Yankees via, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The New York Yankees’ Reggie Jackson, known as “Mr. October,” was a force to be reckoned with. Jackson flourished on the big stage, and his move to the Bronx coincided with the team’s late 1970s renaissance.

He produced remarkable moments with his extraordinary power, including three home runs in a single World Series game. Jackson, a five-time All-Star and two-time World Series MVP is known for his exploits in the postseason.

He became a legendary character both on and off the field because of his swagger and larger-than-life demeanor. Reggie Jackson’s contribution to the Yankees’ championship run cemented his status as one of the greatest clutch players in baseball history.

10. Bernie Williams

For the New York Yankees, Bernie Williams was the total package, combining outstanding hitting, excellent defense, and a composed, endearing manner. He contributed significantly to the team’s late 1990s and early 2000s success as the center fielder and cleanup hitter, earning five All-Star selections.

Williams won four Gold Glove Awards and was equally skilled with a bat as a glove. His playoff clutch hitting, highlighted by a.297 batting average, contributed to four World Series victories. Along with his talent, Bernie was beloved by his audience for his kind demeanor and passion for jazz guitar. Williams is still regarded as a revered Yankee legend and a benchmark for success.

11. Don Mattingly

M. Alan Loveless, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Throughout his successful career, Don Mattingly, popularly referred to as “Donnie Baseball,” was the lifeblood of the New York Yankees. He won nine Gold Glove Awards for his outstanding play at first base, demonstrating his defensive brilliance.

Mattingly won the 1985 American League MVP award thanks to his consistency at the plate, which helped him become a recurrent All-Star. Although injuries ruined his career, his commitment and leadership remained unwavering.

Through his influence on the Yankees and his persistent fan appeal, Mattingly leaves behind a lasting legacy. He continues to be a legendary character in the franchise’s past, standing for greatness and devotion.

12. Andy Pettitte

The New York Yankees’ Andy Pettitte was the picture of playoff brilliance and dependability. On the mound, his cool manner belied his ferocious intensity. One of the most successful left-handed pitchers in MLB history, Pettitte had a spectacular 19-year career that featured 256 victories.

He amassed a record 19 postseason victories because of his spectacular playoff efforts, making him the all-time leader in that category. Pettitte was a key member of several World Series championship teams and was renowned for performing well under duress.

He became a beloved Yankee and a lasting representation of championship success thanks to his professionalism, work ethic, and leadership.

13. Phil Rizzuto

Stanley Kubrick for LOOK Magazine, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The 1940s and 1950s saw Phil Rizzuto, sometimes known as “The Scooter,” play a key role in the New York Yankees’ success. He became a fan favorite due to his outstanding shortstop abilities and tenacious play. Five-time All-Star Rizzuto had a significant role in many World Series victories.

In addition to his defensive abilities, the Yankees’ potent lineup benefited from his small-ball playing style and bunting prowess. His work flowed smoothly into radio, where he spent decades as the Yankees’ unmistakable voice. Phil Rizzuto left a lasting impression on the Yankees’ illustrious past as both a player and a broadcaster.

14. Ron Guidry

When the New York Yankees were at the height of their powers in the late 1970s, Ron Guidry, affectionately nicknamed “Louisiana Lightning,” was the team’s ace pitcher. He was a powerful force on the mound because of his blazing fastball and great control.

One of the finest individual pitching performances in history was Guidry’s outstanding 1978 campaign, during which time he earned the Cy Young Award with a 25-3 record and a 1.74 ERA. He played a significant role in both World Series victories.

Guidry won over admirers with his understated confidence and competitive energy. His status as one of the greatest pitchers in Yankees history will go on forever in the team’s illustrious past.

15. Jorge Posada

Keith Allison, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A pillar of the New York Yankees’ dynasty in the late 1990s and early 2000s, Jorge Posada was a role model for consistency and leadership. Posada was renowned for his outstanding offensive output and his ability to manage a pitching staff while serving as the team’s starting catcher.

He was a five-time All-Star and a significant part of four World Series victories. Posada’s ability to switch-hit and his clutch-hitting skills made him a fan favorite, and the league respected him for his job behind the plate.

His leadership, devotion to the group, and embodiment of the Yankee spirit cemented his status as one of the greatest players in franchise history. The legacy of Jorge Posada is still felt by Yankees fans today.

16. Thurman Munson

Thurman Munson was a well-liked leader both on and off the field. He was the heart and soul of the New York Yankees in the 1970s. Munson’s tenacity and perseverance as the team’s captain and catcher were exemplars of the time. He won the 1976 American League MVP award and was a seven-time All-Star.

Munson was unmatched in his abilities to manage a pitching staff and play defense. He routinely produced clutch hits offensively. Tragically, an aircraft disaster in 1979 claimed his life. The memory of Thurman Munson lives on in the hearts of Yankee supporters as a moving reminder of a gifted player whose career was sadly cut short.

17. Paul O’Neill

Delaywaves, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Paul O’Neill, sometimes known as “The Warrior,” was a significant contributor to the New York Yankees’ revival in the 1990s. He became a fan favorite due to his fierce competitiveness and clutch hitting. O’Neill, a five-time All-Star, excelled in the outfield and had a strong bat.

From 1996 through 2000, the club won four World Series titles during his stint in the Bronx. His leadership and passion set the tone in the clubhouse in addition to his accomplishments on the field. Paul O’Neill became a beloved character in the history of the organization because of his love for the game and dedication to winning.

18. Elston Howard

Elston Howard, the New York Yankees’ first African-American player in 1955, was a trailblazer for the franchise. As a catcher, he was known for his talent and elegance behind the plate. Two Gold Glove Awards and 12 All-Star selections went to Howard.

His attacking ability was also obvious since he routinely delivered crucial hits. Howard, who won the American League MVP award in 1963, was a crucial member of the Yankees’ championship teams in the late 1950s and early 1960s.

His impact goes beyond baseball since he paved the way for subsequent generations of African-American players and is still viewed as a model of tenacity and brilliance.

19. Graig Nettles

New York Yankees via, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

The outstanding third baseman Graig Nettles was a key component of the New York Yankees’ success in the 1970s. He won two Gold Glove Awards for his unrivaled hot corner defensive prowess. Nettles was renowned for his dexterous and clutch performances, frequently foiling rivals with amazing stops.

His power hitting, which included a career-high 37 home runs in 1977, greatly aided his offensive performance. He was crucial to the victories of two World Series.

Nettles became a fan favorite and a representation of the Yankees’ comeback period thanks to his grit and tough style of play. His reputation as one of the best third basemen in the team’s history lives on in baseball legend.

20. Goose Gossage

In the late ’70s and early ’80s, Goose Gossage, sometimes known as “The Goose,” was a powerful force for the New York Yankees. He established a benchmark for superiority in the late innings as a hard-throwing relief pitcher.

Opposing batters feared Gossage’s menacing demeanor on the mound, complete with a bushy mustache. He played an important role in the Yankees’ 1978 World Series victory and appeared in nine All-Star games throughout the course of his career.

Gossage was renowned for his fierce competition, and his trademarks were his resilience and capacity to smash the door when under duress. The Yankees will always hold a special place in his career as one of the most feared relievers in baseball history.

21. Jorge Posada

Switch-hitting catcher Jorge Posada personified what it meant to be a real New York Yankees icon. Consistency, leadership, and championship achievement characterized his 17-year career. Posada, a five-time All-Star, was well-known for his offensive skills.

In his career, he collected over 1,600 hits, including 275 home runs. He had a key role in the Yankees’ late ’90s and early ’00s dynasty, which produced five World Series titles, and his ability to manage the pitching staff and call games.

Posada won over fans with his devotion to winning and love of the game. His place among the all-time greats of the club is cemented by his devotion to the pinstripes and his contribution to the team’s success.

22. Robinson Canó

The talented second baseman Robinson Canó, who played for the New York Yankees, had a unique combination of power and finesse. His steady batting and fluid left-handed swing earned him six All-Star honors while wearing pinstripes.

Canó made significant offensive contributions, having numerous seasons with 30+ home runs. He twice won the Gold Glove Award for defensive play. He was a crucial member of the Yankees’ playoff teams and contributed to the team’s 2009 World Series victory.

Canó became a fan favorite due to his classy appearance and baseball knowledge. Although he switched organizations, his reputation as a top second baseman in Yankees history endures.

23. Roger Maris

By memorably surpassing Babe Ruth’s single-season home run record in 1961 while donning the recognizable pinstripes of the New York Yankees, Roger Maris cemented his place in baseball history.

He won the American League MVP title for that memorable season because to his 61 home runs. In addition to being a powerful hitter, Maris was a two-time Gold Glove-winning outfielder who made a key contribution to the Yankees’ early 1960s success, which included back-to-back World Series victories in 1961 and 1962.

Through his modest manner and outstanding accomplishments, Maris cemented his status as a Yankee icon and a figurehead of baseball history.

24. Allie Reynolds

The New York Yankees’ championship success in the 1940s and 1950s was largely due to Allie Reynolds, a strong pitcher during those years. Reynolds was known for being an expert in big-game situations, earning the moniker “Superchief.”

He contributed significantly to five straight World Series triumphs from 1949 to 1953 and pitched two no-hitters. His legacy as a playoff legend was cemented by his outstanding postseason performance and incredible 1.10 ERA in World Series play.

Because of his reliability and capacity for success, Reynolds became a pillar of the Yankees’ dynasty and a lasting emblem of championship success in the Bronx.

25. Mel Stottlemyre

As a veteran for the New York Yankees, Mel Stottlemyre demonstrated dependability and superiority as a pitcher and subsequently as a productive pitching coach. Stottlemyre won 164 games over his 11-year playing career with the Yankees and was selected to the All-Star team five times.

He became a fan favorite in the 1960s thanks to his consistency on the mound. A new generation of pitching talent was helped develop by Stottlemyre when he went from playing to coaching, most notably as the Yankees’ pitching coach during their late ’90s dynasty. His services to the Yankees—as a player and a manager—remain a vital part of the organization’s illustrious past.

26. CC Sabathia

The Yankees’ fortunes changed in 2009 when CC Sabathia moved to New York. The squad benefited from the leadership, talent, and unflinching resolve of the gigantic left-handed pitcher.

In his debut season, Sabathia’s commanding presence on the mound paid off as he assisted the Yankees in winning their 27th World Series title. His consistency as the team’s ace pitcher was essential during their postseason campaigns.

Sabathia’s influence was seen off the field as well; he was admired for being a clubhouse leader and a role model for younger players. A tribute to his talent and integrity, his legacy is entwined with the Yankees’ contemporary championship period.

27. Dave Winfield

During his time playing for the New York Yankees in the Bronx, Dave Winfield added strength and athleticism to the outfield. His entry in 1981 signaled the start of a decade of supremacy.

Winfield, a 12-time All-Star, was renowned for his ability to play many outfield positions and for having a powerful bat that produced more than 200 hits in three different seasons.

The success of the squad in the 1980s was greatly attributed to his leadership and work ethic. Winfield won over fans with his ability to perform well under duress and assisted the Yankees in winning the 1992 World Series. The historic past of the team and the fans’ memories of him as a great Yankees player endure.

28. Jorge Posada

The Yankees’ tenacious catcher Jorge Posada served as the foundation of their dynastic run in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Together with his defensive abilities, his switch-hitting brilliance made him a priceless asset.

Posada, a five-time All-Star, was renowned for both his ability to lead a pitching staff and his offensive contributions. The Yankees won four World Series during his career thanks in large part to his playoff leadership and clutch hitting.

Posada has cemented his spot among the best catchers in Yankees history and in the hearts of fans thanks to his devotion to the club and his constant dedication to perfection.

29. Bob Meusel

Power-hitting outfielder Bob Meusel was essential to the New York Yankees’ early championship success in the 1920s. Meusel, a member of the renowned “Murderers’ Row” lineup, was well-known for his ability to drive in runs and hit home runs.

He played an important role on three teams that won the World Series in 1923, 1927, and 1928. Meusel became a feared player in the squad due to his capacity to perform under pressure. His fame survives in Yankees history as a symbol of the team’s rise to prominence and baseball’s thrilling and vibrant Roaring Twenties period.

30. Tino Martinez

The New York Yankees’ late ’90s title campaigns saw a huge contribution from the dependable first baseman Tino Martinez. His clutch play and power-hitting won him a unique place in Yankee fans’ hearts. Martinez’s contributions were especially clear during the postseason when he contributed significant hits and played excellent first-base defense.

His steadiness and leadership in the middle of the lineup were crucial to the Yankees’ four World Series championships between 1996 and 2000. The significance of Tino Martinez to the team’s dynasty underlines his significance in the illustrious past of the organization.

31. David Cone

With one outstanding day in 1999 when he threw a perfect game, still one of baseball’s most coveted and unusual accomplishments, David Cone cemented his place in New York Yankees annals. Cone played a significant role in the Yankees’ late-’90s dynasty, displaying both his pitching prowess and composure under pressure.

He was a five-time All-Star and was essential to four World Series victories. Cone won over fans with his ability to perform well under duress and rise to the moment. His perfect game serves as evidence of his brilliance and cemented his reputation as one of the Yankees’ most enduring pitchers.

32. Tommy Henrich

The New York Yankees’ success in the 1930s and 1940s was greatly influenced by Tommy Henrich, commonly referred to as “Old Reliable,” an adaptable outfielder. His reliability at the plate and versatility in the outfield made Henrich a useful player.

He was known as “Old Reliable” by fans and teammates for his clutch hitting, which won him the moniker. Henrich demonstrated his propensity for winning on baseball’s highest stage by playing on seven World Series-winning teams.

His unrelenting dependability and consistent output made him a pillar of the Yankees’ championship dynasty and a cherished figure in the organization’s illustrious past.

33. Roy White

Unknown to many, Roy White was a multi-talented outfielder with the New York Yankees whose talents extended beyond the numbers. He was a great addition to the team because of his consistent play in the outfield and versatility in the lineup.

The team’s success was greatly aided by White’s capacity for stealing bases, getting on base, and scoring runs. He contributed to two World Series championship teams and constantly performed under pressure.

White gained respect in the clubhouse because of his diligent work ethic and 15-year commitment to the Yankees. His reputation among Yankee supporters as a dependable and selfless player continues to be treasured.

34. Mel Allen

For many generations of baseball fans, Mel Allen—the legendary voice of the New York Yankees—became associated with the sport. How about that? which served as the centerpiece of his unusual presenting style, and brought the game to life for listeners.

Allen gained authority because of his extensive knowledge and love of baseball, and his captivating narrative enthralled listeners. He presided over some of the most notable events in Yankees history, including several championship victories.

Beyond the broadcast booth, Mel Allen’s contributions to the game shaped how fans viewed and valued baseball, leaving an enduring imprint on the sport and its illustrious past.

35. Vic Raschi

Vic Raschi, a powerful pitcher for the New York Yankees, was a key contributor to the group’s post-war championship triumph. Raschi, who was renowned for his commanding fastball and potent slider, was selected to three All-Star games and played a significant role in the Yankees’ World Series victories in 1949, 1950, and 1951.

He was a trustworthy ace thanks to his competitive spirit and ability to execute under duress. Raschi became one of the team’s most renowned pitchers and a representation of their championship heritage because of his services to the Yankees’ pitching staff during their dominant run in the late 1940s and early 1950s.

36. David Wells

David Wells, a talented and flamboyant left-handed pitcher, gave the New York Yankees’ squad a distinctive personality. Wells, who is well known for his candor and larger-than-life manner, gave an equally impressive performance on the field.

He made baseball history in 1998 by pitching a perfect game for the Yankees. Wells was an important part of two World Series victories and a three-time All-Star. Fans adored him for his gutsy attitude and capacity to perform under duress.

Despite spending only a brief amount of time in pinstripes, David Wells had a lasting impression on Yankees history as both a great pitcher and a charismatic individual.

37. Bobby Murcer

The 1980s saw Ron Hassey, a talented catcher, contribute significantly to the New York Yankees. Hassey offered consistency behind the plate and was well-known for his defensive skills and ability to manage a pitching staff.

He also participated in two perfect games, one for the Yankees in 1985 and the other for the Cleveland Indians in 1981, which is a singular accomplishment in baseball history.

He was a valued member of the team in the clubhouse, and his contributions went beyond the diamond. Hassey is regarded as a revered character in Yankees history, personifying quality and dependability because of his track record as a trustworthy catcher and his participation in important events.

38. Joe Gordon

Pitcher Chase Whitley established himself with the New York Yankees, demonstrating his adaptability and tenacity. Whitley’s versatility and dedication to the team’s success were highlighted by his ability to go from a starter to a relief.

He underwent Tommy John surgery, which had its difficulties, but he persevered and made a successful comeback. Whitley’s time with the Yankees was very brief, but his contributions and his willingness to overcome hardship serve as an example of the traits the team values.

His path serves as a reminder of the commitment and perseverance needed to don the pinstripes and play baseball at the greatest level.

39. Herb Pennock

The legendary left-handed pitcher Herb Pennock, often known as “The Knight of Kennett Square,” made a lasting impression on the New York Yankees and baseball during his distinguished career.

Pennock had unmatched accuracy on the mound and was essential to the Yankees’ early championship triumphs in the 1920s. Being a skilled artisan with perfect control, he had a reputation as one of the best southpaws in the game.

Pennock gained the moniker “The Squire of Kennett Square” for his ability to produce under pressure. With five World Series victories to his record, he has cemented his status as a Yankee icon and played a crucial part in the illustrious past of the team.

40. Jack Chesbro

The early history of the New York Yankees (then the Highlanders) is interlaced with the contributions of “Happy Jack,” a pioneering pitcher. Chesbro was known for his spitball pitch and unwavering work ethic.

He was a strong competitor. He had one of the most outstanding seasons in baseball history in 1904, winning a record-tying 41 games. The Highlanders’ first American League pennant was made possible by his dominant performance on the mound.

The influence Jack Chesbro had as a Yankees pitcher and his amazing 1904 season stand as a monument to his brilliance and tenacity, influencing the team’s early baseball years.

41. Spud Chandler

A talented right-handed pitcher named Spud Chandler was essential to the 1940s triumph of the New York Yankees. Chandler, who was well-known for his sinkerball and a reliable performer, won the American League MVP award in 1943, an uncommon distinction for a pitcher.

That season, he topped the league in wins and ERA, demonstrating his prowess on the mound. Chandler, who was renowned for his ability to perform in crucial moments, contributed to four World Series victories.

His cool manner and clutch outings cemented his reputation as a Yankees icon, personifying the winning philosophy of the team at the time and elevating him to a cherished position in baseball history.

42. Carl Mays

Early in the 1920s, the controversial and powerful pitcher Carl Mays had a significant impact on the New York Yankees. His hallmark pitch, delivered in a submarine motion, was unusual and difficult for batters to handle.

Mays, who is still remembered for the pitch that cruelly hit and killed Ray Chapman of the Cleveland Indians in 1920, was a key player in the Yankees’ first-ever American League pennant victory in 1921.

Although Mays’ achievements as a pitcher are obvious, the Chapman incident casts a negative light on his career. Both his distinctive throwing technique and the sad catastrophe that eternally ties his name to baseball history leave a lasting impression.

43. Red Ruffing

Red Ruffing, a tenacious and powerful right-handed pitcher, symbolized the 1930s and 1940s New York Yankees championship period. His transformation from a Hall of Fame pitcher to a struggling minor league outfielder is amazing. Ruffing was a pillar of the pitching staff for the Yankees thanks to his blistering fastball and acute curveball.

He led the squad to six 20-win seasons and seven World Series victories. Ruffing was renowned for his stoicism on the pitch and consistency under duress. His reputation as one of the best pitchers in Yankees history persists, serving as an example of tenacity and skill in the quest for championship success.

44. Earle Combs

During the 1920s and the beginning of the 1930s, Earle Combs also referred to as “The Kentucky Colonel,” played center field for the New York Yankees. Combs, a vital cog in the famed “Murderers’ Row” lineup, laid the groundwork with his tremendous hitting and quickness.

He was a four-time All-Star and the winner of three World Series victories. Combs was a key factor in the Yankees’ success because of his extraordinary center-field coverage skills and his propensity for often reaching base. His reputation survives as one of the team’s early stars, standing for the Yankees’ heritage of brilliance and championship success.

45. Bill Dickey

Legendary catcher Bill Dickey was the driving force behind the New York Yankees in the 1930s and 1940s. Dickey, who was well known for his outstanding pitching control and defensive prowess, played a significant role in the team’s dynasty. He was a 14-time All-Star and a member of the Hall of Fame.

He had a powerful bat, collecting over 1,700 hits and batting above 300 during his career. Seven World Series victories were made possible by Dickey’s strong leadership and clutch hitting.

He gained respect around the league for his austere style and dedication behind the plate. In Yankees history, Bill Dickey has stood as a lasting representation of quality and the winning heritage of the team.

46. Tony Lazzeri

Poosh ‘Em Up Tony,” a talented second baseman, was a key component of the New York Yankees’ early championship triumphs in the 1920s and 1930s. Lazzeri blended power and elegance as a member of the storied “Murderers’ Row” lineup, collecting more than 1,800 hits and more than 1,000 RBIs throughout his career.

His mobility in the infield and leadership skills were advantages. Lazzeri was a member of five World Series champion teams and was chosen for five All-Star games. One of the Yankees’ early stars due to his ability to deliver under pressure, he is still regarded as a beloved figure in the team’s illustrious past.

47. Charlie Keller

In the 1930s and 1940s, the New York Yankees’ left fielder Charlie Keller, often known as “King Kong,” was a fearsome player who provided the team with power and consistency. Keller, a four-time All-Star outfielder with a strong bat, played with Joe DiMaggio and Tommy Henrich in the storied Yankees outfield.

He was a crucial offensive force because of his capacity to hit for both average and power. Keller played on four World Series champion teams and provided important hits.

His career was cut short by injuries, but his contribution to the Yankees’ triumph and his image as a dangerous hitter are immortalized in the team’s history as a symbol of an era of hegemony.

48. Johnny Mize

The productive first baseman known as “The Big Cat,” Johnny Mize, had a lasting impression on the New York Yankees in the 1940s. He was an overwhelming offensive force thanks to his strong swing and consistency at the bat.

Mize, a member of the Hall of Fame, had a significant role in five World Series victories. He was a 10-time All-Star who frequently performed admirably under pressure.

Mize became a revered character among Yankees supporters due to his capacity to adjust under duress and his composure at the plate. His position in baseball history is cemented by his reputation as one of the finest first basemen in team history and by his contribution to their championship dynasty.

49. Phil Niekro

At the end of his spectacular career, legendary knuckleball pitcher Phil Niekro joined the New York Yankees. Niekro, who was renowned for his extraordinary endurance and reliability, played with the Yankees from 1984 to 1985. He pitched a perfect game for the squad in his 300th career triumph.

Niekro became well-known due to his performance that defied his age and his knuckleball’s capacity to confuse hitters. He was a five-time All-Star and a Hall of Famer with more than 300 victories. Niekro’s time with the Yankees, albeit being brief, gave the team a special touch and highlighted the continuing fascination of his mysterious fastball.

50. David Robertson

David Robertson was a brilliant bullpen pitcher with the New York Yankees, earning the nickname “Houdini” for his amazing ability to get out of difficult situations. Robertson was a potent late-inning weapon because of his arsenal of offerings, which included a deadly curveball.

He served in that capacity from 2008 to 2014 and once more in 2017. He constantly performed well under pressure. Robertson, along with Mariano Rivera, and Rafael Soriano, were essential members of the Yankees’ “Three-Headed Monster” bullpen.

His reputation as a trustworthy setup man was cemented by his countless strikeouts and significant postseason performances. Robertson’s tenure in pinstripes served as a showcase for his resiliency and grit, giving him the moniker and a place in Yankees fans’ hearts forever.


Baseball has been forever changed by the luminaries who have shaped the New York Yankees’ illustrious past. The Yankees have a long history of having a wealth of talent, from Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig to Derek Jeter and Mariano Rivera.

These 50 players have helped the Yankees become one of the most prosperous and recognizable sports clubs in the world, each with their own special contributions and flashes of brilliance. The pinstripes will always be synonymous with excellence thanks to their heritage of inspiring fans and the next generations of baseball players.